Haha...This a pissing match between personal preferences.

I dunno why, but the 08-09 STIs look super sexy as black. I like WR Blue Mica for my Year. But, my second color would be black.
Hmm...random thought. I know the WR blue, black, and the grey have some flake added to the paint. But, what about the Aspen white? I don't see to many of those around here.